He fails and shakes tomato sauce all over Princess Carolyn and the bedroom. Paige questions about the boy. In fact, it's because of Mr. Peanutbutter's compulsively supportive habits (and questionable intelligence) that BoJack is able to snag his dream role as Secretariat. Mr. Peanutbutter and Pickles make out while the space station explodes up above. Mr. Peanutbutter asks Jessica why she's afraid of Mummies. Meanwhile, Todd calls Mr. Peanutbutter again and tells him that his idea to start including male customers was a success, loving the safe spaces for women more than the women themselves. They reveal that they're burning the clothes, as opposed to removing the stench, because Carolyn said to "get rid" of them prior. At the end of The Telescope, BoJack kisses Diane, leaving things awkward for the two in the following episode, Horse Majeure. She wonders why Mr. Peanutbutter does things for her because she's such a disaster, but Mr. Peanutbutter says she's just Diane and that he'd do anything for her. BoJack tries to give her a compliment, but Diane's response is taken the wrong way. She gets a text from Alexi Brosefino, a famous movie star and member of the entourage "The Snatch Batch," and how he wants her to party with him that night so that she can take Instagram pictures. He takes out the engagement ring she threw at him earlier and asks if she still wants to marry him. Although off-screen, BoJack reminds Mr. Peanutbutter that he was in a rehab facility, and Mr. Peanutbutter subsequently leaves. Mr. Peanutbutter and Pickles get hungry, but Pickles says that restaurants are a date thing. Joey then wishes Pickles best of luck with the wedding and that he hopes to have what Pickles has with Mr. Peanutbutter. On the set of Birthday Dad, BoJack and Mr. Peanutbutter are filming a war scene and BoJack is cast as a dead soldier. Mr. Peanutbutter tells her he has always tried to be an "us" with people. Paige tells her husband they are back from New Mexico and still on the trail of their story. Mr. Peanutbutter leaves the house and approaches Pickles. She is not excited to see him either, but explains that his heroic deeds have intrigued someone she works for and that she now has an opportunity for him: she asks if he wants to be the governor. Mr. Peanutbutter instead encourages her to go talk to BoJack, who just got a phone call from his mother, and is asking if it could wait. She says that he keeps dating women in their twenties, so they aren't fully formed yethe doesn't ruin them they just grow up. Before leaving, Katrina asked Mr. Peanutbutter to not leave her alone during the party, as she didn't know anyone there, and Mr. Peanutbutter agreed. He proposes to her in the season finale to avoid admitting he cheated on her by sleeping with Diane. He sternly tells BoJack "OK, that's enough." All the while Diane forced herself to pretend to support her husband. He approaches Jessica Biel while Mr. Peanutbutter watches in dismay. He confesses that he cheated on her twice a few months ago with Diane, much to Pickles grief, and she throws the ring again and starts screaming at such a high frequency that the glass window shatters. Mr. Peanutbutter returns with two different types of boba, one with whip cream and one without after Pickles gets out of the bath. Philbert picks up the landline phone in his bedroom, where he gets the news that the police chief was murdered. When Mr. Peanutbutter asks BoJack why he dislikes him, BoJack admits that he is jealous. When Sassy asks him why he still has a landline, he says it was his wife's, and Fritz is seen strangling her. Flip and Diane emerge with new script pages and try to gather everyone around so that they can film, but since they're behind they have to shoot it all at once with cue cards. The two then engage in passionate a. When Mr. Peanutbutter hears her crying from downstairs he decides to go talk to her and runs upstairs while everyone except Princess Carolyn, Todd, and Ruthie quickly leave the house. His high energy, unpredictability, impulsiveness, and inability to actually listen makes him rather exhausting when it comes to relationships, especially here where romance is concerned. He recalls her not loving Starbucks, but loving the independent coffee place, although Starbucks is more convenient, showing Diane he does listen. In The Stopped Show, Mr. Peanutbutter goes to visit Diane, wanting to talk about how they had sex after the Philbert premier. Joey offers to go into business with him and Mr. Peanutbutter takes the offer. Later, Mr. Peanutbutter picks up Diane from the airport. Pickles goes on to say that she can tell that Mr. Peanutbutter feels guilty. She says that he won't always be her only priority. Princess Carolyn meanwhile begins contacting a landscaper. He goes on to say that if he does nothing then eventually the public will like him again. Mr. Peanutbutter then notices the entire kitchen set from Mr. Peanutbutter's House. While she was in a relationship with Mr Peanutbutter, BoJack planted a kiss on her lips but she was not interested in reciprocating the affection whatsoever. She's not too bothered by this, because they'll still look cute together. In It's You, Mr. Peanutbutter becomes depressed due to his brother's illness, as he and Todd purchase a new building for Cabracadabra's headquarters. After signing off, Pickles asks Mr. Peanutbutter whats going on, saying that hes been acting differently. Jessica yells at Mr. Peanutbutter for not keeping the mummy away, while also revealing she auditioned to play the actual mummy as she storms off. Mr. Peanutbutter announces to the audience after the break that he forgives BoJack, and then Daniel Radcliffe makes them kiss. Despite Diane constantly voicing her dislike of them, Mr. Peanutbutter constantly tries to impress her with grand gestures because he's scared she'll get bored of him and leave like his previous wives. Flea Daniels tells Mr. Peanutbutter that theyre not going to re-edit the scene because he's already been dragging it out for the longest time, with his ridiculous demands. Princess Carolyn freaks out upon seeing that Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter have started a fire outside. Mr. Peanutbutter then says he went to college in Chicago and Diane tells him Northwestern is not in Chicago. After trying and failing to make it work, Diane confessed she was no longer happy and the two ended up getting divorced in season 5. They are wearing matching costumes inspired by a new social media app called "Tweed Feed," which are tweed outfits with dinner plates, silverware, and plastic food taped to them. Mrpeanutbutter does need to stop and think about his actions before he does them. Mr. Peanutbutter expresses concern, that he and Diane may end up getting a divorce if any more fights break out between themand asks for help removing the skunk scent before she returns home. Disaster Dominoes: BoJack's Halloween parties inevitably seem to be the tipping point where Mr. Peanutbutter's relationships start falling apart, but the one with Jessica Biel takes the cake. When a paparazzo tries to ask Mr. Peanutbutter why he tried to kill himself, Princess Carolyn answers that Mr. Peanutbutter is a sad dog. A teenage Todd and his friends try to trick-or-treat at BoJack's house, but Princess Carolyn turns them away, motivating them to cover the place in toilet . She runs off crying. This refers to twin sisters from the show Mr. Peanutbutter's HouseZelda was a happy extrovert, Zo was a cynical introvert. She takes a selfie with Mr. Peanutbutter and happily exclaims that she never wants to grow up. At the desert, an upset Pickles doesn't want to sit on the blanket with Mr. Peanutbutter. This almost jeopardized Mr. Peanutbutter's job, as he and Hank both work at MBN, he even looked up to Hank growing up, and he started receiving death threats for Diane. During the car ride, Mr. Peanutbutter asks BoJack if he's going to wear his everyday attire to the wedding. The doctor comes in and tells her blood work is good, but not to do any more drugs in the time being because she's pregnant. While Pickles continues talking, neither she nor Mr. Peanutbutter notice the people in their house. He rubs his eyes and he's back in reality. BoJack doesn't have a costume so asks Princess Carolyn for help. Mr. Peanutbutter rescues BoJack and tells him what happened. As Diane angrily cleans up, Mr. Peanutbutter asks if she wants to talk about it. Princess Carolyn suggests they take a tomato bath. They attended BoJack's Halloween Party in 2004, where Jessica wanted them to dress like the lead characters from the movie The Notebook, but Mr. Peanutbutter ends up dressing as an actual notebook. In the meat locker, Pickles asks how much longer they have to continue working with Joey. They run past BoJack, who is at the Cinnabunny. Pickles questions why not and Joey tells her he has a hard time because he has trouble finding someone who gets his brand. In between takes, Mr. Peanutbutter remarks how much fun they are having filming together. Diane says she's good in small groups and shouts that she hates parties, which interrupts the party. When Princess Carolyn tries to leave, Mr. Peanutbutter asks her if she wants to keep hanging out, and pitches her movie ideas inspired by greeting cards. BoJack answers the doorbell, and to his utter dismay finds Mr. Peanutbutter and Pickles, and a crowd of party guests lined up behind them. Mr. Peanutbutter tells the driver to change the station but tells her to go back to the podcast when he alternative announces they'll be playing a new song from Twenty One Pilots. In a flashback to the party, Diane spots Mr. Peanutbutter kissing Pickles, the waitress from the restaurant. Mr. Peanutbutter then tells BoJack he's playing Julius Caesar on the stage next door for a short film. You mean like, like a duel, a duel?" The two are still friendly with one another, but when they arrive back to her apartment Mr. Peanutbutter gives Diane the signed divorce papers. BoJack admits it's because he's jealous that Mr. Peanutbutter feels good about himself, and BoJack doesn't know if he'll ever be able to do that. The show's working title was "Untitled Horsin' Around Knockoff," and BoJack Horseman was resentful of the show because he rightly assumed it was a knockoff, and showed annoyance and resentment towards Mr. Peanutbutter. Diane and BoJack have always had a special, if also complicated, relationship, and with Diane's relationship with Mr. Peanutbutter perpetually on the fritz, season 4 might be the time they. Diane says she's good in small groups and shouts that she hates parties, which interrupts the party. Mr. Peanutbutter asks how he should fix that. Mr. Peanutbutter goes on to say that he loves the meme where the boyfriend is looking at another lady and the girlfriend turns to him with an expression of tremendous pain asking how could a man who claims to love her betray her, saying that its a very sad meme. After they calm down, Diane says she thinks their marriage is like a magic eye poster, as at first glance, it's messy and doesn't make sense, but if you squint hard enough, everything lines up. I mean, at the Halloween party, she reassured Pickles, and said that PB would love her unconditionally, and Diane was no longer the person he loved, now it was her. He is one of the main characters in BoJack Horseman. When Pickles says that shes going to talk to her subscribers, Mr. Peanutbutter begs her not to tweed feed this information. Later, Pickles and Joey finish having sex in the meat locker. At the diner, BoJack asks if Mr. Peanutbutter spends a lot of time with Judah and Princess Carolyn as a couple. The two drive home, acting awkward about talking about the baby, although they had always agreed that they didn't want kids. As he and Mr. Peanutbutter leave Princess Carolyn's office, Todd suggests he and Maude go on a double date with Mr. Peanutbutter and Pickles. It was the fact that PB only knew how to express his love in his way (through huge romantic gestures) instead of recognizing how to actually connect with her. Following, she grabs her keys and heads out to aid them. He goes on to say they want to help him share his story with the world much Mr. Peanutbutters surprise. Mr. Peanutbutter explains this is the first time hes ever felt that way and doesnt know how to handle itto which Diane retorts back that he should feel that way, the two then get up in each other's faces as they argue, before making out and beginning to have sex again. She tells Pickles Mr. Peanutbutter is fully devoted to whoever he is in a serious romantic relationship with and she tells Pickles that she's that girl now. She Got a Haircut Pickles excitedly says she has to go and gives Mr. Peanutbutter a final hug and kiss thanking him for everything before running off. After Princess Carolyn tells him Mr. Peanutbutter perks his ears up when he says the correct answer, he begins to win. Max counters no she is in love with him even though she'd never admitted it to herself. However, it's caused some problems, because they're starting to rate drivers on how attractive they are. BoJack replies he's sure he'll find a way to mess things up. Mr. Peanutbutter decides to try and toughen up his image. Back in the present, Diane tells Mr. Peanutbutter that she's really happy for him. She tells him as Diane can live her life whole life like pieces of a puzzle from different sets. An annoyed Katrina tells him she wants to leave, saying she's not having fun because she doesn't know anyone at the party, but instead Mr. Peanutbutter makes her talk to BoJack, who leaves her too after realizing he needs a Halloween costume. In Higher Love, Mr. Peanutbutter's frustrated accountant Oxnard tells him PB Livin' is bankrupt due to him and Todd going through with terrible business ideas. Mr. Peanutbutter says if they keep brainstorming, they can come up with a guy for Pickles to cheat on him with and things can be totally even, and everything can go back to normal and they can get married. Mr. Peanutbutter asks for credit for the surprise party, in which Diane says she didn't want it. Either Diane refused to take Mr Peanutbutter's money because she wants to be independent and would see it as a sign of weakness or she wanted to be able to maintain a good relationship with him afterwards and felt that if he had to send her a check every month, that wasn't going to happen. His wife, Jessica Biel, tells him she meant the movie The Notebook, as she's dressed like Rachel McAdam's character, Allie Hamilton, from the movie. He tells Sassy to get dressed so they can get to the bottom of this because this times it's "personnel.". She then breaks her left wrist in an attempt to carry Mr. Peanutbutter into their bedroom. BoJack realizes that all his suspects: Flip, Princess Carolyn, Diane, and Mr. Peanutbutter, revolve around the showdeveloping the conspiracy theory the whole show was created to reveal his secrets. She says she doesn't want to be in a routine as an old couple. BoJack replies officially it's breaking and entering but he believes it's kind of for everything. Princess Carolyn approaches Mr. Peanutbutter and she is confused when she spots Joey Pogo driving through the set. Mr. Peanutbutter then realizes that all of his ex's used to be fun, but turned bitter and cruel after being with him but can't figure out the common denominator. Though a seemingly odd couple at the beginning of the show, they have a sweet and productive relationship: Diane's sardonic intellect is balanced by Mr. Peanutbutter's blithe attitude. He tells Diane that he keeps taking amazing women and ruining them. Mr. Peanutbutter convinces her to stay home for the time being. Diane says she isn't jealous either and leaves. This was after Jimmy Fallon, the original host, was hit with a bus and "broke his face." He tells Diane on the phone the lazy Susans at his restaurant became problematic as they were offensive to Susans. Max says sure he puts on a good front and puts up a good fight but if Pickles were to confess her love it would drop his heart down an elevator shaft and bring it back up to his throat. As he approaches Mr. Peanutbutter and Princess Carolyn, Princess Carolyn pushes Mr. Peanutbutter in front of Joeys car, and Mr. Peanutbutter is left slightly puzzled when he doesnt get hit by Joeys slow-moving car. BoJack then asks why the set looks like his house. Pickles reconciles with Mr. Peanutbutter, and Diane leaves, saying she's gonna take someone's helicopter home-seeing that she is unable to reach her car. She runs into Mr. Peanutbutter who compliments her haircut but leaves her to talk to Erica. BoJack explains these are the clothes he went in with and didn't realize he would be going to a wedding in a year. He tells BoJack that when his mom got old they sent her to a farm. They all barge in. Mr. Peanutbutter shows the latter problem after he cheats on Pickles by sleeping with Dianeand he asks her to break the news to Pickles, which Diane rightfully refuses to do. Mr. Peanutbutter then excused himself as Katrina had her hand down a busboy's pants. Pickles is introduced in The Dog Days Are Over in Season 5, where she begins dating Mr. Peanutbutter as his divorce with Diane is being finalized. Joey then apologizes for being awful to Pickles earlier and says since Mr. Peanutbutter has been such a good friend it would be weird having sex with his fiance but once they were in it it felt like "two naked hearts raw and exposed but safe in the home they found in each other." Diane then comes to the front door and apologizes to Pickles for cheating, saying it was her fault, and it'll never happen again. BoJack brings this up but denies to Diane he wants to talk about it. When Mr. Peanutbutter is commended for destigmatizing mental illness, he comments that it all worked out depressingly.". A security guard comes and allows him to leave for the weekend to attend Princess Carolyn and Judah's wedding. Mr. Peanutbutter finally admits this is true and apologizes to Diane for being dismissive and not really listening to her throughout their relationship in their phone conversation in Angela. She goes on to say Mr. Peanutbutter can't do hurtful things anymore because it's not OK. Todd reluctantly agrees. He also says he knows it doesn't really work that way. Mr. Peanutbutter says that he thinks he screwed things up really badly and maybe he should just wait for Pickles to come to him. BoJack takes a selfie outside of the Capital building and posts it on Instagram, and the first comment is from Mr. Peanutbutter telling him to turn around. Diane then tells him she's moving to Houston with her boyfriend. As viewers, we were invested in their. He announces at dinner with Diane, Princess Carolyn, and her new boyfriend Ralph Stilton that hes selling Cabracadabra. Diane hates those huge gestures because she feels like it puts pressure on her to do the same, or at least be dazzled by it even if she didn't want it in the first place. Mr. Peanutbutter starts to say they should set a date for the wedding but he is interrupted by Pickles telling him about the job opportunity with Joey Pogo. The whole "i understand and appreciate you" thing, where they try to fix their marriage, has already been used. Sassy wakes up, and Philbert tells her the pieces are starting to fit together. He approaches Jessica Biel while Mr. Peanutbutter watches in dismay, as his notebook costume was too wide to let him run through the door to protect her. Mr. Peanutbutter asks when he's getting out for real and BoJack responds that it'll be a few months. Pickles then suggest sleeping with both Buzzy and Tyler from Soul Cycle. He agrees, and she asks for no more surprise parties. She was afraid so she wanted the security and sense of loyalty he provides. Princess Carolyn, at first, assumes he needs a body buried; which initially shocks Mr. Peanutbutter. When she changes her mind, he agrees to make Pickles her favorite drink. Despite his happy-go-lucky demeanor, there are traces of nihilism in him, believing "the key to being happy is to just distract yourself with unimportant nonsense until you eventually die.". BoJack says his only goal currently is not to screw up this weekend. Diane goes to the party alone but runs into Todd. Paige says she only tolerates him for work otherwise she can't stand him. Outside, Mr. Peanutbutter runs into Princess Carolyn and Judah and tells them sadly he is giving away Pickles' favorite alcoholic energy drink seeing that he doesn't need it anymore, as Pickles no longer lives with him. He then puts it back in his pocket unopened. Everyone leaves as Princess Carolyn says that the party is over. He is then approached by Joey Pogo. He goes on to say that he was in the thunder room for months trying to swallow his shame. Diane is afraid of not finding happiness and thought it might be best to get those fleeting moments of joy that Mr. Peanutbutter can offer. Mr. Peanutbutter realizes that they need video evidence of him being tough. Pickles tells Joey she will see him later and he puts his hoodie on her shoulders when he realizes she is shivering. Diane ends up making a fool of herself in front of BoJack, who interrupts her and coldly tells her he's on the phone, as unbeknownst to her his mom was telling him that his father died. He also dislikes change, as he didn't want Diane to go to Cordovia. Princess Carolyn prepares to calls a cleaning service, while Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter take care of their foul-smelling clothes. Like real-life dogs, he can't eat chocolate (it's poisonous to them), watch fireworks or listen to loud noises (dogs have sensitive ears). She says Mr. Peanutbutter doesn't even know Buzzy. However, he does leave her alone multiple times to talk to and party with the other guests, with Katrina becoming more upset and angry throughout the night. This starts an argument where Mr. Peanutbutter says that at least no one in his family has anger issues, saying that Pickles father Franco is "a hothead with a little pug complex," and that her mother more than likely provokes him on purpose, suggesting that they get off on it. She goes on to say that she noticed it on the night of the Philbert premiere when Mr. Peanutbutter came home late smelling like Diane, and then things went back to normal, but then he started acting weird again shortly before he proposed when he came home smelling like Diane again. In The Shot, as he agrees to play Nixon's dog Checkers. It's only natural for Dianne and Peanutbutter to drift apart. BoJack tried to protest the scene to Flip, saying if he's trying to get back at him for criticizing the script he shouldn't also punish Gina in the process. We learn valuable lessons through their antics, and they remind us how imperfect we are as humans and how heavily our own thoughts can affect us. Afterward, Mr. Peanutbutter tells Diane there's a woman in the restaurant he's at that looks just like her, which makes her laugh, although it is unknown if Mr. Peanutbutter was joking or if he was actually being serious. Mr. Peanutbutter says she didn't, and that he loves her and wants to know the real her. In 2007, he wore a blue and red "Swan Dutch" hat, a black Ed Hardy-style t-shirt with a design on the front that included a dog skull over crossbones with the words "Fetch, Sit, Stay" in it, grey-blue acid-washed jeans, olive green sneakers, and three bracelets, a pink, red, and neon green bracelet respectively, on his left wrist. Mr. Peanutbutter and BoJack concoct a plan to distract the public while the 'D' is hauled away by Mr. Peanutbutter's helicopter. Diane then questions him writing a memoir and he says it was remarkably easy for him. Mr. Peanutbutter remains downstairs trying to get himself a glass of water while at the same time not noticing Princess Carolyn and Todd crawling around his kitchen floor with Ruthie. He apologizes to her, and when asked how he could do that he tells her that it was the worst mistake of his life. The two realize theyre both pretty happy, which worries them, and they quickly run off to start the tour and get the word out on depression. It's to just keep yourself busy with unimportant nonsense, and eventually, you'll be dead.Mr. Diane returns and is now looking for the owner of a blue Tesla. Diane mentions the divorce papers but gets interrupted by the waitress, an excitable pug lady named Pickles, who gets along with Mr. Peanutbutter. In BoJack Hates the Troops, he briefly filmed for a reality show titled Peanutbutter and Jelly. He goes on to say that the people who dislike him the most are young women, much to Princess Carolyns dismay who says that young women are part of their main target demographic for Birthday Dad and she tells him that they need to juice [his] Q." The next morning BoJack wakes up to Mr. Peanutbutter cooking breakfast. Mr. Peanutbutter ends up proposing to Pickles, instead of telling her the truth, setting the cycle of all his failed marriages back in motion. Mr. Peanutbutter says that they're here for the Halloween party that he's had for the last eleven years, as BoJack always says at the end of the parties to do it again next year. She notices a cardboard cutout that looks like Mr. Peanutbutter behind a bookcase and discovers he wrote a memoir. Mr. Peanutbutter apologizes and says he got distracted by the fun party. Mr. Peanutbutter thinks he knows about something between him and Diane, but BoJack doesn't. Mr. Peanutbutter then gets back in the car and BoJack tells him he wants to go back to prison as he doesn't feel like he can be around people. Mr. Peanutbutter appears behind him and after BoJack questions why hes here, he explains hes the face of depression, to BoJacks confusion. Mr. Peanutbutter arrives to confirm his suspicions of BoJack having feelings for Diane by stealing the 'D,' but offers to help BoJack return the 'D' secretly under the condition BoJack stops pursuing Diane romantically.